Boys
| 5:44.42 | Cameron Haught (17 Yellow Springs, OH) | 2017 | 711 |
| 5:47:59 | Zachary Pollinger (04 North Highlands, NJ) | 2003 | 648 |
| 5:56.90 | Juan Moscoso (19 Longwood, FL) | 2017 | 462 |
| 5:57.37 | Samuel Allen (20 Woolwich, NJ) | 2020 | 452 |
| 5:57.90 | Paul Tavares (90 Centereach, NY) | 1990 | 442 |
| 5:59.73 | Alejandro Chavez (11 Pharr, TX) | 2011 | 405 |
| 6:04.0 | Ricardo Vergara (08 Edinburg, TX) | 2008 | 320 |
| 6:04.08 | James Spahr (92 Smithtown West, NY) | 1991 | 318 |
| 6:09.37 | Sean Albert (92 Paramus, NJ) | 1991 | 212 |
| 6:11.50 | Clayton Stoil (23 Langley, VA) | 2023 | 170 |
| -10- | |||
| 6:16.10 | Sean Glaze (20 Springfield, OH) | 2019 | 78 |
| 6:16.75 | Darren Eames (Sachem, NY) | 1993 | 65 |
| 6:18.84 | Tim Seaman (90 North Babylon, NY) | 1990 | 23 |
| 6:22.86 | AJ Gruttadauro (16 Brockport, NY) | 2015 | |
| 6:23.4 | Dave Talcott (NY) | 1983 | |
| 6:23.4 | Bob Maffucci (Mamaroneck, NY) | 1979 |
Girls
| 6:02.85 | Taylor Ewert (20 Beavercreek, OH) | 2019 | 1043 |
| 6:17.59 | Lauren Harris (17 Sachem East, NY) | 2017 | 748 |
| 6:28.20 | Lisa Kutzing (98 Port Jefferson, NY) | 1998 | 536 |
| 6:28.46 | Heather Durrant (23 Elgin, IL) | 2023 | 530 |
| 6:30.8 | Deborah Iden (93 Bayport-Blue Point, NY) | 1993 | 484 |
| 6:31.87 | Madison Morgan (25 Episcopal, TX) | 2023 | 462 |
| 6:33.67 | Isabella Rogler (20 West Islip, NY) | 2020 | 426 |
| 6:36.51 | Meaghan Podlaski (15 Colonie, NY) | 2015 | 369 |
| 6:36.8 | Melissa Baker (94 Shoreham, NY) | 1993 | 364 |
| 6:38.38 | Amelia Cuomo (17 Brewster, NY) | 2017 | 332 |
| -10- | |||
| 6:39.99 | Maria Michta (04 Sachem, NY) | 2003 | 300 |
| 6:40.09 | Taylor Farrell (24 Corning, NY) | 2024 | 298 |
| 6:41.12 | Christy Finke (04 Fairport, NY) | 2003 | 277 |
| 6:41.65 | Talia Green (24 Oakland, CA) | 2023 | 267 |
| 6:42.9 | Kirsten Jordan (01 Rye, NY) | 2001 | 242 |
| 6:42.9 | Jen Frost (93 Pelham, NY) | 1993 | 242 |
| 6:44.57 | Ciara Durcan (21 Pearl River, NY) | 2019 | 208 |
| 6:44.62 | Ji Won Kang (13 Townsend Harris, NYC) | 2013 | 207 |
| 6:45.00 | Annica Penn (13 Westhampton Beach, NY) | 2013 | 200 |
| 6:45.14 | Andrea Albergo (00 Penfield, NY) | 2000 | 197 |
| -20- | |||
| 6:45.78 | Danielle Opatovsky (11 Shoreham, NY) | 2011 | 184 |
| 6:46.66 | Leah Bulletti (09 Westhampton, NY) | 2007 | 166 |
| 6:48.17 | Laura Richenderfer (04 Penfield, NY) | 2004 | 136 |
| 6:48.54 | Holly Lindoe (13 Sachem East, NY) | 2013 | 129 |
| 6:49.09 | Margaret Atwood (18 Sachem East, NY) | 2018 | 118 |
| 6:49.32 | MariaAngelica Garcia (16 North Rockland, NY) | 2016 | 113 |
| 6:49.44 | Katie Michta (14 Sachem North, NY) | 2014 | 111 |
| 6:49.82 | Ariana Cagnina (17 Sachem North, NY) | 2017 | 103 |
| 6:49.99 | Kayla Allen (17 Lewiston, ME) | 2017 | 100 |
| 6:50.68 | Sydney Sirois (17 Greene, ME) | 2017 | 86 |
| -30- | |||
| 6:50.81 | Katharine Newhoff (15 East Islip, NY) | 2015 | 83 |
| 6:51.07 | Alexa Kluepfel (14 John Glenn, NY) | 2013 | 78 |
| 6:52.6 | Jenna Monahan (07 Sachem East, NY) | 2007 | 48 |
| 6:53.06 | Crosby Tillman (11 Somers, NY) | 2011 | 38 |
| 6:53.57 | Taylor Nugent (25 Sweet Home, NY) | 2024 | 28 |
| 6:54.48 | Desilets Dubois (24 Brockport, NY) | 2024 | 10 |
| 6:54.68 | Anali Cisneros (16 Elgin, IL) | 2016 | 6 |
| 6:55.09 | Brittany O’Brian (07 Bay Shore, NY) | 2006 | |
| 6:55.2 | Roselle Safran (95 Brentwood, NY) | 1993 | |
| 6:55.54 | Kelsey Jordan (17 Westhampton Beach, NY) | 2016 | |
| -40- | |||
| 6:55.79 | Abby Callinan (24 Sachem East, NY) | 2023 | |
| 6:56.03 | Kate Cannon (06 Somers, NY) | 2006 | |
| 6:56.15 | Jamie Yedowitz (99 Rye, NY) | 1999 | |
| 6:56.46 | Jennifer Halloran (11 Bay Shore, NY) | 2011 | |
| 6:56.80 | Stephanie Saccente (13 Kings Park, NY) | 2013 | |
| 6:57.08 | Emily Porti (20 East Islip, NY) | 2020 | |
| 6:57.21 | Rachel Tylock (11 Penfield, NY) | 2011 | |
| 6:57.38 | Ashlyn Poulin (23 Gardiner, ME) | 2023 | |
| 6:58.79 | Audrey Fox (18 New Rochelle, NY) | 2018 | |
| 6:58.94 | Jessica Grover (19 Half Hollow Hills East, NY) | 2018 | |
| -50- | |||
| 6:58.94 | Analiese Fabrizi (21 Sachem North, NY) | 2020 | |
| 6:59.03 | Alexa Governor (23 Williamsville Central, NY) | 2023 | |
| 6:59.46 | Grace Endy (21 Westfield, NJ) | 2019 | |
| 6:59.47 | Gianna Mauri (25 Sachem East, NY) | 2024 | |
| 6:59.51 | Samantha Benson-Tyler (26 Port Washington, NY) | 2024 | |
| 6:59.56 | Monika Farmer (15 Connetquot, NY) | 2013 | |
| 6:59.72 | Nayeli Cisneros (17 Elgin, IL) | 2016 |