Boys
| 20:06.0 | Trevor Barron (10 Bethel Park, PA) | 2010 | 1052 |
| 21:12.90 | Will Van Axen (93 Connetquot, NY) | 1991 | 964 |
| 21:53.80 | Jared Swehosky (05 Salem, OR) | 2005 | 911 |
| 22:06.0 | Cameron Haught (17 Yellow Springs, OH) | 2016 | 896 |
| 22:08.66 | Kevin Eastler (95 Mt Blue, ME) | 1994 | 892 |
| 22:12.25 | Justin Marrujo (94 CA) | 1994 | 887 |
| 22:17.0 | Greg Dawson (85 Smithtown, NY) | 1985 | 882 |
| 22:18.0 | Alejandro Chavez (11 Pharr, TX) | 2011 | 881 |
| 22:18.10 | Benjamin Shorey (01 Ellsworth, ME) | 2001 | 880 |
| 22:21.19 | James Spahr (92 Smithtown West, NY) | 1992 | 876 |
| -10- | |||
| 22:29.0 | Josh Ginsburg (95 Walt Whitman, NY) | 1995 | 868 |
| 22:29.58 | Curt Clausen (86 Stevens Point, WI) | 1986 | 866 |
| 22:30.94 | Zachary Pollinger (04 North Highlands, NJ) | 2004 | 865 |
| 22:31.0 | Ed O’Rourke (80 Glen Cove, NY) | 1980 | 865 |
| 22:34.73 | Samuel Allen (20 Woolwich, NJ) | 2020 | 860 |
| 22:36.0 | Scott Crafton (97 North Central, IN) | 1997 | 859 |
| 22:40.92 | Tim Seaman (90 North Babylon, NY) | 1990 | 853 |
| 22:46.0 | Anthony Peters (14 Bartlett, IL) | 2014 | 847 |
| 22:47.1 | Tom Magee (81 Monroe-Woodbury, NY) | 1981 | 844 |
| 22:48.0 | Tim Lewis (80 Shenendehowa, NY) | 1980 | 844 |
| -20- | |||
| 22:52.4 | Troy Engle (79 Scarsdale, NY) | 1979 | 838 |
| 22:53.0 | Brian Colby (99 Edgewood, WI) | 1996 | 838 |
| 22:57.0 | Alexander Peters (14 Elgin, IL) | 2012 | 833 |
Girls
| 22:38.16 | Taylor Ewert (20 Beavercreek, OH) | 2018 | 1030 |
| 23:00.78 | Anya-Maria Ruoss (94 Fayetteville, AR) | 1994 | 1004 |
| 23:31.20 | Ashleigh Resch (15 Beavercreek, OH) | 2015 | 970 |
| 23:37.20 | Heather Durrant (23 Elgin, IL) | 2023 | 963 |
| 23:38.0 | Lisa Kutzing (98 Port Jefferson, NY) | 1998 | 962 |
| 23:59.0 | Emma Carter (98 Overland Park, KS) | 1998 | 939 |
| 24:04.42 | Deborah Iden (93 Bayport-Blue Point, NY) | 1993 | 933 |
| 24:06.47 | Angelica Harris (23 Elgin, IL) | 2023 | 930 |
| 24:08.60 | Talia Green (24 Oakland, CA) | 2022 | 928 |
| 24:11.0 | Robyn Stevens (01 Vacaville, CA) | 1999 | 925 |
| 24:14.56 | Katharine Newhoff (15 East Islip, NY) | 2015 | 922 |
| -10- | |||
| 24:16.2 | Sue Brodock (74 Rome, NY) | 1974 | 920 |
| 24:17.06 | Lauren Harris (17 Sachem East, NY) | 2017 | 919 |
| 24:19.58 | Lisa Chumbley (93 Houston, TX) | 1993 | 916 |
| 24:22.93 | Meaghan Podlaski (15 Colonie, NY) | 2015 | 912 |
| 24:24.60 | Heather Buletti (06 Westhampton, NY) | 2006 | 911 |
| 24:29.18 | Melissa Baker (94 Shoreham, NY) | 1993 | 906 |
| 24:33.17 | Anali Cisneros (16 Elgin, IL) | 2016 | 901 |
| 24:36.80 | Maria Michta (04 Sachem, NY) | 2002 | 897 |
| 24:49.2 | Samantha Cohen (96 Albany, NY) | 1996 | 884 |
| 24:52.06 | Alexa Governor (23 Williamsville Central, NY) | 2023 | 881 |
| -20- | |||
| 24:59.0 | Katie Rulapaugh (99 Sheffield, IA) | 1999 | 874 |
| 24:59.9 | Alison Zabrenski (96 Bowie, MD) | 1996 | 873 |